French Vintage HiFi 
  • Hardware
  • Music
  • Interviews & Reviews
  • Links
  • Contact us

AW Audio EA 16

03/03/2012

0 Comments

 
Picture
In 1987, Alain Wacquet introduced the third and unfortunately last installment of his EA series of electrodynamic panels.
He would later introduce a "Transparence" upgrade, but this product never became a proper commercial reality. I understand Alain still have a few pairs of these magic panels. If anybody is interested, let me know via our "Contact Us" page and we will put you in touch with Alain.

But back to the EA 16 now!
Alain sent me a copy of a review of these products in HIFI Video, June 1987 issue, and I will try to extract the useful information out of it for you in English. I will also give you access to the original text.
So, it is confirmed, as I have suspected from day one, that EA 16, stands for 16 drivers, which implies that the EA 11 and EA 12 had, guess how many, 11 and 12 drivers respectively...
We also get confirmation that all the drivers are in a single vertical line, and in the EA 16 at least, the midrange and tweeter are further back from the woofers. From the impedance curve, we can derive that the panel has its main resonance around 70Hz, which correlates well with the lack of rock-bottom bass. However, because of the small diameter of the drivers, the 94dB/1W/1m efficiency, and the proper time alignement, the impulse response and the dynamic range are second to none.
I have found recently that the AUDAX WTF12 is the main driver. Its efficiency is 90dB/1w/1m and its free air resonance 87Hz, which confirms the above, and which shows up in the impedance curve below.
Even the best electrostatic panels have difficulty to compete with the EA16s, not a mince feast. The closest I have found are actually the Magnepan panels.
Alain is a jazz music guru, and these panels are certainly very well equipped to properly render the small jazz ensembles and the intimate venues that are usually associated with them.
I don't think I have ever heard percussions, and primarily skins rendered with such accuracy and realism.
The EA 16 compare in size with the Martin Logan CLX and the KS-10 from KingSound (out of Honk Kong) at 90cm wide by 140cm high (vs 178.6cm × 65.4cm for the ML and 196cm x 76cm for the KS)

Picture
To emphasize that the balance, dynamic range and impulse response are more important to the auditive result than a perfectly flat and extended measured response, it is interesting to note that this is the case for the EA16s.
A slight emphasis in the 200 to 300Hz region improves the subjective impression of enough bass, specially when teamed up with a dip in the midrange and a controlled cut-off in the treble (the curve below may not be accurate in the treble due to the large size of the panel and the positioning of the measuring microphone, however it correlates well with the listening experience...)
Picture
These were expensive speakers at the time and also because of their size would sound best in a large room where you could have them well away from all walls, but then you would be rewarded by one, an extraordinary wide, stable and accurate image and two, a dynamic range and timbral accuracy second to none.
The reviewer at HIFI Video concludes: "The system has the efficiency and energy of a compression speaker, the tonal balance of the best electrodynamic system and the "finesse" of an electrostatic panel."
The best of all worlds then? Maybe not, but certainly one of most rewarding listening experience in my book!

see original review below.
Picture
Add Comment
 

Paris Hifi show 2011 - W to A - Micromega, Metronome, Martin Logan, Magnepan, McIntosh

10/12/2011

0 Comments

 

Micromega: from the best of analogue to HD Audio digital

Picture
Micromega became famous in the 80s for being the umbrella for some of the most amazing products of the time, namely the LEEDH speakers by Gilles Milot, and the Epure turntable, designed by Pierre Riffaud and still in production.
Gilles Milot is now the brains behind Acoustical Beauty, with some very innovative new speakers - see further article.
Didier Hamdi, the new owner of Micromedia has stirred the ship towards more digital products (but still making amps and an FM Tuner, a rarity in today's market) and was beautifully demonstrating his new wifi streamer and D/A converter: the Aria AirStream. He was also using one of the most amazing speakers: The AvantGarde acoustic Duos
But the most important part of his demos was the fact that he was very convincingly proving that a native 16bit/44.1kHz file - whether streamed or out of a Red Book CD - was actually a better sounding proposition than an up sampled version of it (24/96 0r 24/192), as there is no way to extract more information from that format, whichever clever electronic trick you put out of your D/A converter hat!
I am planning to write an in depth article on this subject in the New Year, so stay tuned.
Micromegaa is promising to get you the best out of your iTunes library by carefully designing power supplies, sampling clock(s), and analog circuitry with a choice of XLR balanced outputs or Cinch unbalanced ones.

Metronome Technologie: the best CD player on the planet?

Picture
After working on CD players and their related electronics since 1987, Metronome Technologie believe they have the best machine on the market in the shape of their money is no object Kalista and Kalista Reference, both using a Philips Pro CD transport and external electronics. You could  a weekly dinner for 18 months at Guy Savoy , or once a year for the rest of your natural life for the price of one of these futuristic acrylic and metal contraption. But if your are more of an HiFi freak than a gourmet, the Kalista will provide you with hours of unadulterated sonic pleasures. If you still want to afford Guy Savoy some time, then Metronome has released some more affordable versions of their player. This year, they were introducing the CD8, a one box solution based on the same transport and a simplified set of valve and solid state electronics and a more reasonable price ( 7700 euros/11000$).
It comes with an USB input into the 24/192 D/A converter.

Martin Logan - less expensive as the years go by...

Picture
You probably know that I have a sweet tooth for the brand and specially for the Ethos released 18 months ago. (photo)
Well, it seems they really want each and every one of us to own a pair of these fabulous electrostatic panels, as they just introduced the new Electromotion series at a fraction of the price of the Ethos (about 1000$ on Amazon...)
I have not have a chance to listen to them, but it is certainly something to investigate! 
And yes, they still look stunning with their very high WAF index!

Magnepan - the electrodynamic cousin of the Martin Logans

Picture
Introducing a quasi ribbon technology speaker, Magnepan is competing directly with Martin Logan and in the same price range (2000$ a pair in the US of A). The breakthrough is that the ribbon is now backed by a mylar film giving a strength to the ribbon, improving power handling and probably reducing distortion.
It is to be noted that due to the large emissive surface of the speaker, it does not need an extra subwoofer and claims to go down to 40Hz on its own.
It was only on static display, so I cannot confirm if these claims are legitimate.
However, Magnepan has been in business for 41 years: it speaks volumes (sic!) 

McIntosh: the Rolls Royce of the amplifiers world?

Picture
What an impressive display of power!
You need to be very confident of your position in the marketplace to dare having only a static display - albeit of epic proportions!

Add Comment
 

Salon Hifi 2010 - Paris - From A to W: Atohm to Waterfall Audio

16/10/2010

0 Comments

 
Today, I will review the two brands/products that have most impressed me in terms of speaker design and new to me.
Atohm and Waterfall Audio are kind of cousins as Thierry Comte is a partner in Waterfall, and the main driver (sic...) behind Atohm.
Besides, Waterfall Audio uses almost exclusively Atohm speakers.
Both companies have created a range of speakers that have some design criteria in common, but have achieved very different products out of some of the same components.
Atohm drivers are all high efficiency and both bass and midrange drivers have a metal membrane. Their top of the range tweeter however has a silk membrane and a 28mm diameter coil small enough to always stay within the humongous magnetic field of more than 17000 Gauss, resulting in a massive 98db/w/m efficiency.
We were exposed to their top model, the GT 3.0, a so-called 3.5 way freestanding speaker beautifully finished and equipped with 2 7inch bass drivers, 1 6inch medium with a phase plug and the above mentioned supertweeter.
The crossover frequencies are 100, 150 and 2500Hz, hence the 3.5 way name.
All filter slopes are 6db and the tweeter is time aligned.
The midrange driver has its own chamber fitted with an internal conical structure aimed at taming the standing waves and reflections inside that cabinet. This is reminiscent of the structure in the B&W Nautilus, but inverted inside the cabinet.
The bass drivers are installed in a bass reflex enclosure with a laminated vent at the base of the speaker's cabinet (like in our Microphase SWS subwoofer, this arrangement removes most of the potential problems linked with the floor structure and the position within the room).
The very well conducted demo showed the accuracy, speed and time alignment of this speaker, highly respecting the timbres of instruments and at 92db efficiency and 300W power capacity, reproducing the music with a realistic level and a total absence of distortion. Definitely in my top five at the show.
Their cost of 7,900 euros + seems to be the norm at that level of quality (Elipson 4260, Vienna Acoustics, or my favourite Martin Logans are twice the price...)
Waterfall Audio has taken a different approach, using some of the same drivers, in their top model, the Niagara.
First of all, Waterfall has made a name for themselves by introducing glass cabinets for their speakers.
We all know that glass is a very inert material, but being transparent, one cannot hide much inside the cabinet. Besides, it is quite a difficult material to process and assemble, more so once you add the complexity of a horn in front of the tweeter!
But Cedric Aubriot and Thierry Combe are not the types to refuse a challenge, and they came up with a number of innovative ideas to make this speaker a "chef d'oeuvre" in the sense of the Compagnons in the Middle Ages.
The result is a beautiful objet with a very high WAF - they have their Export Manager, Nadine, as their first judge, and she has convinced women (and men, I am sure...) in 30 countries to agree with her and buy this wonderful object!
Having said that, the auditive result is totaly in tune with the aesthetics of the product, proving once more that form should follow function if one wants to achieve the best possible results in any field. Electroacoustics are still full of "black magic" and in this case a transparent one: the filter is hidden in the base of the speaker, and so is the larger passive bass driver. Again, the midrange driver has its own enclosure baptised Acoustic Damping Tube, and the bass is generated mainly by a second 7inch driver. The tweeter is a 21mm diameter with a silk cone behind the proprietary glass horn. All drivers are bespoke versions of Atohm drivers.
The sound is solid, accurate and neutral. At 89db and 200w power handling, the output is realistic with a very nice, precise soundstage.
At 27,000 euros, this is not for the faint hearted, but a tenth of the price of a Focal Utopia and a lot easier to fit in one's living room. And with all due respect to Jacques Mahul, a much more lively proposition, more engaging with the source material, and, after a relatively short audition, certainly not less accurate.
It is to be noted here that Len Wallis (of Len Wallis Audio fame in Sydney) has given me access for a full morning to the Utopia in his showroom with two of his most knowledgeable sales people (and vinyl enthusiasts on top...) as my 60th birthday present...and so, my opinion of the Utopia is based on a much longer listening session on my own material. Although we had probably hal a million dollars of equipment in that room, I cannot say I was totally convinced mainly because it was almost surgical and lack the passion to engage my senses totally.
So, if I had a spare 40,000A$, I would certainly consider the Niagara!
I would like to try them with my Bryston amp and a Michell turntable and Grado Signature cartridge. Maybe the Aussie distributor of Waterfall Audio can organise that for me ( I will BYO my amp!!!)
Add Comment
 

    Author

    Born in France, well travelled, relocated to Sydney in 1997.
    Loves to cook for family and friends from seasonal and local ingredients and listen to live and recorded music, the subject on hand here!
    I am an electronic engineer by trade, speaker designer of some fame in the mid 80s, now involved in techncal and architectural products for the Building Industry.
       www.archinterface.com.au
    I also blog on food, wine and travel, focused on all things French:
    www.ourfrenchimpressions.com

    Picture
    Flag Counter

    Archives

    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010

    Categories

    All
    2012 International Ces
    215 Rtf
    24/192
    24/96
    320kbps
    384/32
    4040
    4240
    4260
    6moons
    96khz/24bit
    A31
    Acapella
    Acoustical Beauty
    Advance Audio
    Aeolus
    Aerosystem One
    Agilent
    Aiff
    Alain Calmettes
    Alain Wacquet
    Alexa
    Ambronay Editions
    Amplifiers
    Analog Collector
    Andre Charlin
    Android
    Anne Sophie Mutter
    Anniversary
    Antelope Audio
    Apple
    Aria 5
    Astin Trew
    At5
    Atohm
    Audax
    Audioaccess
    Audioanalyse
    Audioconnection
    Audioconnexion
    Audioconseil
    Audio Dynamics
    Audiolineaire
    Audio Note Japan
    Audio Trends
    Australian Hifi Magazine
    Australian HiFi Show 2012 Sydney
    Australian HiFi Show 2012 Sydney
    Aw Audio
    Aw Audio Ea 16
    Axente
    Bc Acoustique
    Bee Jaz
    Bergman
    Bergmann Magne
    Blog
    Bmr
    Braun
    Brett Whiteley
    Bryston
    Bs50
    Cabasse
    Cabasse Artis
    Cabasse In Australia
    Cabasse Ocean
    Cabinet
    Cabinet Design
    Calliope Cd Player
    Canor
    Carol Anne Cassidy
    Cd
    Cd1
    Cedia
    Cedric Leon
    Ces 2012
    Chambord
    Chinese New Year
    Christophe Cabasse
    Classique
    Clement
    Compact Disc
    Consonance
    Cote Paris
    DA 650
    DA 750
    DAI 1CHI
    Dan D'Agostino
    D'Appolito
    Dave Wilson
    Da Vinci
    Davis
    Davis Acoustics
    Denis Beau
    Design Principles
    Devialet
    Dgg
    Diatone
    Digital Downloads
    Dire Straits
    D Premier
    Dual Turntable
    Duocell
    EA 11
    EA 12
    EA 16
    Ead
    Ecm
    Edison
    Electrocompaniet
    Electrodynamic Panels
    Elipson
    Elipson 4050
    Elipson 4260
    Elipson Bs50 Tribute
    Elipson In Australia
    Elipson Planet L
    Elipson Religieuses
    Elipson Studio Pro
    Encel Stereo
    Epure
    Era Turntable
    Europe Audio Diffusion
    Evaanna Manley
    Filter
    Flac
    Flamingos
    Foam Suspension
    Foca
    Focal
    Focal. JM Lab
    Form And Function
    Fostex
    French Product At The Ces 2012
    French Products At The Ces 2012
    Ft96h
    Full Range
    Full Range Speakers
    Fx120
    Galaxy
    Garrard 401
    George Cabasse
    Georges Cabasse
    Ghislain Prugnard
    Gilles Milot
    Grado
    Gramophone
    Grande Utopia Em
    Grand Utopia Be
    Group Delay
    Grundig
    Guarneri Memento
    Guy Hf
    Harman Kardon
    Hd212 Pro
    Hdtv
    Helma Paulson
    Helmholtz
    Heritage
    Hewlett Packard
    Hifi Antique
    Hifi News
    Hifi Stereo Magazine
    Hifi Video
    Hifi Vintage
    High Efficiency
    High Efficiency Loudspeakers
    High End Show Munich
    Holst
    Hp
    Icon Audio
    Ina
    International Dynamics
    Interview
    In Wall Speakers
    Ion Tweeter
    Ipad
    Iphone
    Ipod
    Ipod Dock
    Ise Amsterdam
    Isokinetic
    Itrax
    Ja500
    Ja80
    Jacki Pugh
    Jacques Mahul
    Jadis
    Japanese Vintage Hifi
    Jarre
    Jarre Technologies
    Jc2 Bp
    Jc3
    Jc Verdier
    Jean Hiraga
    Jean Jacques Capello
    Jean Marie Hubert
    Jean Marie Raynaud
    Jean Michel Jarre
    Jean Paul Guy
    Jean Paul Guy
    Jmb Acoustique
    Jmlab
    Josef Svalander
    Joseph Leon
    Jullien Thaler
    KC X1
    Kef
    Ken Kessler
    Kenwood
    Kingsound
    KM X1
    Kondo
    Kreon
    Ktr Lab
    Kuzma
    Laborie. Oppo
    La Maison Du Haut Parleur Paris
    Langsche
    La Sphere
    Las Vegas
    Leedh
    Len Wallis Audio
    Le Studio Hifi
    Linkwitz Riley
    Linn
    Loudspeakers
    Lyra
    Magnepan
    Mamiya
    Manley Labs
    Marcel Rochet
    Marc Fontaine
    Martial Hernandez
    Martin Logan
    Martin Logan Ethos
    Martin Viktorin
    Mcintosh
    Melbourne
    Melbourne Hifi Show October 2011
    Membranes
    Memphis Slim
    Meridian
    Metronome
    Metrum
    Michell
    Michell Orbe
    Michel Visan
    Micromega
    Microphase
    Microphase Csw
    Microphase Triton
    Micro Third Four
    Midi
    Minute
    Mirare
    Momentum
    Morel
    Mosfet
    Mp3
    Mulidine
    Music
    Nad
    Niagara
    Nikon
    Norway
    Novotel Paris Tour Eiffel
    Nuvo Technologies
    Ocean
    Ocellia
    Olympus
    Ondine
    Onken
    Open Baffle
    Oppo
    OPPO BD 95
    Oracle Audio Technologies
    Origin Live
    Ortophon
    Otl
    Parasound
    Paris
    Paris Hifi Show
    Paris Hifi Show 2011
    Pascal Louvet
    Passion Elipson
    Passion Elipson
    Patrick Vercher
    Philippe Lesage
    Philips CD PRO II
    Phl Audio
    Pierre Breart
    Pierre Clement
    Pierre Lurne
    Pierre Riffaud
    Planet L
    Plus Loin Music
    Point Musiques
    Pro Ject
    Qobuz
    Radiance
    Recital 12
    Rega
    Rega Arm
    Renaud De Vergnette
    Rj Baffle
    Rohde & Schwarz
    Rubber Suspension
    Salon De La Hifi Et Du Cinema
    Salon De La Hifi Et Du Cinema Paris 2011
    Salon De La Hifi Et Du Home Cinema
    Salon De La Hifi Et Du Home Cinema 2011
    Salon Hifi Paris 2012
    Salvator Dali
    Samsung
    Sanken
    Sasha
    Sats
    Seas
    Season Greetings
    Secam
    Senheise
    Shanling
    Siare
    Signature
    Small Speaker
    Sme Arm
    Soledge
    Solen. Impedance Compensation
    Solid State
    Sonab OA 14
    Sonus Faber
    Sooloos
    Soolos
    Sophie Marceau
    Soulution 540
    Spat
    Speakers
    Spearkers Corner Records
    Sphaeron Excalibur
    Sphere
    Steinway Lingdorff
    Stellavox
    Stenheim
    Stormaudio
    Sub 10
    Subwoofer
    Supravox
    Suspensions
    Sweden
    Tangential Arm
    Tangential Arm Turntable
    Td 350
    Td 550
    The Bellagio
    The Bellagio Las Vegas
    The Decca Sound
    T.H.E. Show 2012
    T.H.E. Show Las Vegas 2012
    T.H.E. Show Vegas
    The Venetian
    Thiel
    Thorens
    Thrax Audio
    Time Alignment
    Tosca
    Traffic
    Triangle
    Triangle 1180
    Tributaries Cables
    Triphonic
    Tubes
    Turntables
    Tw8 Tweeter
    Unison Research
    Utopia
    Valves
    Verve
    Vicoustic
    Vienna Acoustics
    Vintage Hifi
    Vinyl
    Violet
    Vismes
    Voigtlander
    Wagner Electronic Services
    Waterfall Audi
    Waterfall Audio
    Watt/Puppy
    Wilson Audio
    Winter & Winter
    Wisdom Audio
    Yba
    Yba Hifi
    Ypsilon CDT 100 CD Player/transport
    Ypsilon Electronics
    Yves Bernard Andre
    Zig Zag Territoires

    RSS Feed